A federal judge blocked part of an Ohio law late Thursday that bans the abortion method of dilation and evacuation in most cases, adding to a list of restrictions on the procedure that are or soon could be in legal limbo.
Senior U.S. District Judge Michael Barrett in Cincinnati ordered the state not to bring criminal charges against doctors who perform the D&E procedure under most circumstances until the case can be fully litigated. Other parts of the law were allowed to proceed.
The ruling comes as the state’s ban of abortions in cases involving a Down Syndrome diagnosis also is before the courts, and the ACLU plans a court challenge to a heartbeat abortion ban signed last week.
The ban on D&Es , the most common second-trimester abortion procedure, was signed by then-Gov. John Kasich last year. In Thursday’s ruling, Barrett agreed with Planned Parenthood the law is likely to be declared unconstitutional because it places an undue burden on a “large fraction” of Ohio women.
Dr. Leana Wen, president of the Planned Parenthood Federation of America, called the ruling a victory for patients’ rights.
“This ban has no basis in medicine, which is why it has been opposed by the medical community,” she said in an emailed statement. “Women’s health care is health care. Reproductive health care is health care. And health care is a fundamental human right. Planned Parenthood will always safeguard the ability of our patients to access safe, legal abortion, no matter what.”
Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost said he was pleased Barrett “largely upheld the ban on dismembering unborn children while they are still alive.”
“Though we will continue defend the constitutionality of every part of the law, we appreciate the judge’s recognition that Ohio may ban abortion methods that are more brutal than any form of slaughter we would permit to be used on livestock,” Yost said in an emailed statement.
The Ohio law defines D&E as “dismemberment abortion” of a living fetus. Barrett agreed with the plaintiffs that such language creates an “implicit fetal demise” requirement in the law, essentially forcing doctors who perform the procedure to either end the life of a living fetus before conducting the abortion — which can be dangerous, ineffective or both — or not offering the D&E abortion at all.
“D&E is the only pre-viability second trimester abortion method available in the outpatient setting in Ohio,” Barrett wrote. “Without the option of selecting a different method, or the ability to rely on a sufficiently broad medical exception, physicians who perform D&E are presented with a series of (fetal) demise options that layer risks on top of existing risks” — legally for doctors, and physically for their patients. He cited testimony that D&E abortions are safe and take about 15 to 20 minutes.
The state argued those risks are mitigated by an exception written into the law for the life of the mother or “serious risk” to her health.
Barrett rejected that argument, writing, “the medical exception is narrowly drafted at best, and unconstitutionally vague at worst.”
He said graphic and unsettling descriptions of abortion procedures were necessary to include in his ruling, because preventing fetal pain is at the heart of efforts to restrict the procedure. Barrett said the general consensus of the medical community is that a fetus cannot feel pain before about 24 weeks’ gestation, when neural connections to the cortex develop.
Still, he said the state of Ohio’s interest in the case is legitimate.
“(T)he Court finds it unlikely that pre-viability fetuses feel pain,” he wrote. “The Court recognizes, however, the State’s interest in this area to prevent even the possibility.”
Mike Gonidakis, president of Ohio Right to Life, said the state’s largest anti-abortion group is disappointed “yet not surprised” at the decision.
“However, even this judge recognized in his decision that states have greater leeway today to regulate abortion,” he said in an emailed statement. “This clearly demonstrates that it is time to revisit the Casey decision which is what the pro-life movement’s goal has always been.”
———
Follow Julie Carr Smyth at http://www.twitter.com/jcarrsmyth .
